Whilst Gergiev’s distinguished musical career has never been in doubt, Tchaikovsky was initially not so fortunate. Becoming a composer in 1860s Russia was not an easy path, and Tchaikovsky was originally destined for the civil service. Moreover, as an aspiring young composer he was poised between the western classical music tradition and the earthier, folk-inspired one of his native land. If finding his way to a musical career was hard enough, how was he to develop his own compositional language between competing interests?
The symphonies on this disc chart Tchaikovsky’s journey from a conscientious explorer of classical structures to someone altogether freer and more inventive, via the attractive nationalism of Symphony No 2 (the ‘Little Russian’). By the third symphony – a five-movement work lasting nearly fifty minutes – Tchaikovsky has fused folk impulses and dance-like episodes within a larger, more reflective structure. The result is both joyous and convincing. The riddle has been solved.
The lyricism of Tchaikovsky ballet scores pervades all three symphonies, but melodic ideas are subjected to a great deal more rigour – such as intense contrapuntal development (in the final movement of the first symphony) and endless thematic reworkings (eg the third movement of No 2). The composer’s inventive approach to orchestration is remarkable, too. In retrospect it does not seem entirely tragic that the vast Russian civil service did without this particular recruit.
And the interpreter? Having found his way to St Petersburg a century after Tchaikovsky, Gergiev has become almost synonymous with the place, closely associated with its musical traditions and intensely proud of them, too. But as a global musical figure he is always suspended somewhere between east and west, not unlike the young Tchaikovsky himself. Who better to guide us through the composer’s first essays in symphonic form? Gergiev’s adopted orchestra gives a full-blooded performance and the LSO strings appear to have become naturalised Russians under his direction. These are compelling accounts by any standards.
James Mallinson, LSO Live Producer
Subscribe to Society of Sound to download high-quality albums from Peter Gabriel’s Real World Studios and the London Symphony Orchestra. All available in Apple Lossless and studio-quality FLAC. If you already have a Society of Sound membership please sign in